The perfect love story. Until it became the perfect crime.
Newly-discovered facts, court records and speculation are used to elaborate the true love story and murder mystery of the most notorious unsolved murder case in New York history.
30
Cast members loaded
28
Alive
2
Deceased
93.3%
Still living
Showing 30 of 30 loaded cast members.
as David Marks
AliveBorn: November 12, 1980
Age: 45
London, Ontario, Canada
as Katie Marks
AliveBorn: April 30, 1982
Age: 44
Point Pleasant, New Jersey, USA
as Sanford Marks
AliveBorn: January 1, 1938
Age: 88
Bayonne, New Jersey, USA
as Deborah Lehrman
AliveBorn: June 29, 1982
Age: 44
New York City, New York, USA
as Malvern Bump
DeceasedBorn: September 10, 1931
Died: June 12, 2022
Age at death: 90
as Daniel Marks
AliveBorn: December 1, 1976
Age: 49
New York, New York, USA
as Janice Rizzo
AliveBorn: August 10, 1952
Age: 74
East Hartford, Connecticut, USA
as Jim McCarthy
AliveBorn: June 26, 1970
Age: 56
Joliet, Illinois, USA
as Lauren Fleck
AliveBorn: August 22, 1973
Age: 53
Canandaigua, New York, USA
as Todd Fleck
AliveBorn: April 30, 1971
Age: 55
Upper Brookville, New York, USA
as Richard Panatierre
AliveBorn: March 2, 1930
Age: 96
Knoxville, Tennessee, USA
as Mary McCarthy
AliveBirth date not on record.
Rochester, New York, USA
as Sharon McCarthy
AliveBorn: June 27, 1979
Age: 47
Indianapolis, Indiana, USA
as Ann McCarthy
AliveBorn: October 10, 1945
Age: 80
New York City, New York, USA
as Katie's Aunt
AliveBorn: July 9, 1955
Age: 71
Colorado Springs, Colorado, USA
as Katie's Uncle
AliveBirth date not on record.
as Sarah Davis
AliveBorn: January 10, 1967
Age: 59
New York City, New York, USA
as Barry Davis
AliveBorn: August 17, 1959
Age: 67
as Brian Callender
AliveBorn: May 16, 1960
Age: 66
Houston, Texas, USA
as Kelly Callender
AliveBorn: March 27, 1969
Age: 57
Amarillo, Texas, USA
as Mayor
DeceasedBorn: February 19, 1937
Died: January 11, 2016
Age at death: 78
as Sidney Greenhaus
AliveBorn: September 5, 1968
Age: 58
Queens, New York City, New York, USA
as Solly Sachs
AliveBirth date not on record.
as Daniel Patrick Moynihan
AliveBorn: November 17, 1951
Age: 74
Council Bluffs, Iowa, USA
as Moynihan's Wife
AliveBirth date not on record.
as Moynihan's Assistant
AliveBorn: February 8, 1980
Age: 46
Dallas, Texas, USA
as Bonnie Felder
AliveBorn: August 6, 1977
Age: 49
Little Rock, Arkansas, USA
as Divorce Attorney
AliveBorn: December 11, 1955
Age: 70
Dallas, Texas, USA
as Lula Baxter
AliveBorn: November 26, 1959
Age: 66
New York City, New York, U.S.
as Julie Moran
AliveBorn: January 10, 1962
Age: 64
Thomasville, Georgia, USA
30 of 52 cast members loaded